I grew up reading murder mysteries and religiously watching CSI. So, when I saw Murder by Degrees in a bookstore, I was excited! A murder mystery based in Philly with a medical undertone: what could be better?
I hopped onto Libby, an eBook app used by libraries nationwide, to see if the Philadelphia Free Library had a copy, and sure enough, they have several! (Note: The Free Library has a fantastic selection, and if you don’t already have their library card, you should get one! It’s free!). At the time, it didn’t cross my mind that the author, Ritu Mukerji, might have a medical background. After all, plenty of authors pick subjects they’re not intimately acquainted with and do thorough research to write them well.
It was during the first scene set in the anatomy lab that I put down my book, picked up my phone, and searched Mukerji’s background. Cadaveric dissection was described in such an intentional and respectful way; it thoughtfully reflected the medical school anatomy experience in a way that research — no matter how extensive — couldn’t convey. I was sure that Mukerji had been in an anatomy lab. Sure enough, Doctor Mukerjigraduated from Sidney Kimmel and is now a practicing internist in California. Her medical background and experience in Philadelphia added layers and depth to this novel that I appreciated.
The story follows 19th-century physician Dr. Lydia Weston, who finds herself assisting a police investigation after one of her patients turns up dead. The book has an enjoyable mystery plotline, but it’s the other interwoven threads that heightened the novel for me. Aspects of the tale take on issues like health disparities based on socioeconomic status and the fight by early female doctors for respect on the wards. There are also many features that I found relatable as a medical student in Philadelphia: descriptions of the Schuylkill and Wissahickon, challenging pathophysiology questions in lecture halls, patient examinations at free clinics, and morning rounds at Pennsy. Plus, if you listen to your patient’s history closely enough, you might just pick up on an early clue or two…
Despite its many strengths, there were a few moments where portions of the story arc didn’t feel fully fleshed out. For example, Dr. Lydia Weston has an Indian background, much like Mukerji herself, but this was often left as a side detail. Similarly, some of the perpetrator’s actions, when described as part of the big reveal, were illogical to me. They seemed to cater more toward adding drama within scenes or weaving in red herrings, rather than moments that contributed to character and plot development.
Overall, I enjoyed this read and give it 4.5 / 5 stars. Medical students in Philadelphia, particularly those who identify as female and enjoy a good mystery, will find the book engaging and relatable.
As always, check your preferred source for content warnings. Happy reading!
